Just your average friendly neighbourhood radical.

  • 0 Posts
  • 43 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 16th, 2023

help-circle







  • Who did you think presided over colonialism, genius? Martians?

    By the time of the Great Irish Famine (one of the British Empire’s earliest achievements) the transformation of England from a feudal society to a liberal one was complete.

    The US was literally founded as the model for the liberal nation state - it’s entire history of genocide, slavery and yes, colonialism was drenched in the tenets of liberalism from the moment the constitution was signed right to this very day.

    Go redo your history - and, this time, don’t get it from PragerU.











  • Wtf does that even mean?

    Pretending that production for profit and production for need is the same thing is fallacious - end of story.

    All I’m trying to do is explain to you that resources are finite and too many people will burn through them.

    You still haven’t managed to justify the right-wing trope of “overpopulation” - pretending that the vast majority’s consumption is (somehow) the problem isn’t proving it, merely regurgitating it.

    the white people that slowed down the most.

    Sooo… you have figured out that in a capitalist society access to women’s healthcare is merely another commodity - and, thanks to colonialist pillaging and repression, white people do tend to have more access to that commmodity?

    You don’t say.

    Population projections for the world do not show a decline.

    No… it shows a trend towards stabilization - which, just by itself, demoslishes the entire concept of “overpopulation.”

    Unless of course you take the lack of resources into account…

    What lack of resources. Resources being hoarded by a capitalist elite was as true in 1950 as it was in 2023 - so how does that affect the trope you are trying to justify?


  • Water used for industry is still going to be used regardless of who controls that industry.

    Absolutely not. Pretending that capitalism doesn’t work the way capitalism works is a certain dead-end for your argument.

    they just don’t have a means to act on it.

    That is one piss-poor justification for the status quo.

    Population growth has slowed but it has not stopped.

    The people at the top aren’t worried about population growth these days, Clyde - they are worried about population reversal. You wanna know why?


  • Whether Malthus himself was a right-winger or not isn’t really important… it doesn’t change how the trope of overpopulation has been used to protect power and privilege (ie, the whole point of right-wing ideology). For instance, there is a very good reason why white supremacists support the criminalization of women’s health care in (supposedly) “white” countries while demonizing 3rd world countries for their (supposedly) “explosive population growth.”

    It’s a very old trope that flattens human consumption and therefore camouflages the reality that certain classes of people consume resources at astronomical rates in comparison with the rest. It’s utility in shielding class hierarchies from scrutiny should be perfectly obvious.